Does the Bible Contradict Itself?

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised
About the Bible Series
Miracles   -   Timelines   -   Genealogies   -   Errors

Biblical passages sometimes differ in wording, numbers or narrative details. Some apparent contradictions become less difficult when the passages are read in context; other differences remain unresolved without further evidence. A useful answer identifies the exact claims and explains how much a proposed solution establishes. It should neither dismiss a difficult reading nor claim that a possible reconciliation has been proved.

Question considered: Does the Bible contradict itself? Is it full of errors or is it error free?

Does the Bible contradict itself? Is it full of errors or is it error free? Those broad questions need particular examples. This guide compares three cases and gives a method readers can repeat. It does not claim to settle every question about inspiration, copying or historical accuracy. Prepared by LetsLearnTheBible.com.

What Would Make Two Statements Contradict?

First ask whether the passages assert incompatible things about the same matter in the same respect. A report that names one person does not necessarily assert that only one was present. Two accounts that give different totals for the same group present a different problem. The explanation must fit what the sentences actually say.

Also distinguish a difference within the narratives from a difference in the wording of copies or translations. The study of KJV errors, older English and variants and the translation comparison address those subjects separately. Here the starting point is a direct comparison of identified KJV passages, not a ranking of Bible versions.

Does Naming One Blind Man Deny That There Were Two?

In Matthew 20:29–34, two blind men call to Jesus as he leaves Jericho. He asks what they want, touches their eyes and restores their sight. In Mark 10:46–52, Jesus leaves Jericho and the account names Bartimaeus, the son of Timaeus. It follows his call, response and healing.

Mark does not say that Bartimaeus was the only blind person present. His focus on one named man can therefore fit within a scene in which two were healed. That is a limited compatibility argument. It is not proof that we know why Mark selected that man, and it should not be expanded into a claim that all details in every parallel account have been explained.

Luke 18:35–43 shows why the limit matters. Luke introduces a blind man when Jesus comes near Jericho, whereas Matthew and Mark place their scenes at his departure. Saying “one does not mean only one” addresses the number, not that difference in movement. A reconstruction of the route or a claim that these are separate events needs its own argument. This guide leaves that question open. A partial explanation should be identified as partial.

Why Does Jesus Say His Witness Is Not True and Then That It Is?

The contrast is real at the level of the isolated sentences. John 5:31 says, “If I bear witness of myself, my witness is not true.” In John 8:14, Jesus says that although he bears record of himself, his record is true. Reading the surrounding discussion is essential.

In John 5, Jesus immediately speaks of another witness, John the Baptist's testimony, his works and the Father's witness. In John 8, the Pharisees challenge his self-testimony. Jesus replies that he knows where he comes from and where he goes, says he is not alone, and identifies himself and the Father as witnesses. Verse 17 explicitly appeals to the testimony of two men. Compare Deuteronomy 19:15–21, where an accusation requires two or three witnesses and false testimony must be investigated.

A plausible contextual reading is that John 5 considers a claim resting on Jesus' testimony alone, while John 8 defends his testimony and expressly denies that he is alone. Both discussions concern the support for his claim, not a confession that he lies. This reading connects the argument across the paragraphs. It does not require silently changing the KJV word “true” to another English word or claiming a Greek lexical proof that has not been supplied.

Readers may still debate whether that contextual account fully resolves the verbal contrast. What can be checked directly is that neither sentence ends the discussion: both passages go on to name corroborating witness. An interpretation that omits that continuation has not yet dealt with the whole argument.

What About Seven Hundred and Seven Thousand Horsemen?

Second Samuel 8:4 says that David took seven hundred horsemen. The parallel report in 1 Chronicles 18:4 says seven thousand. Both KJV verses also list a thousand chariots and twenty thousand footmen. The surrounding accounts describe David's victory over the king of Zobah.

These are different figures attached to horsemen. Unlike Mark's focus on Bartimaeus, neither number is simply a named individual selected from a larger group. Calling this difference “emphasis” does not explain it.

A copying or transmission problem is one possible kind of explanation. Establishing it in this particular case would require comparing textual witnesses, their readings and the reasons for preferring one. The comparison here is of the named KJV passages; it is not a manuscript collation and does not prove which original number, if either, has been preserved. The numerical discrepancy in the text being read should remain visible while its history is investigated.

A belief about the inspiration of an original text and evidence about the wording of surviving copies are related but distinct questions. Stating that belief does not itself identify a copying mistake or recover the lost wording. The separate study of Old Testament transmission explains the kinds of witnesses and comparisons such an inquiry needs.

How Can You Test a Proposed Explanation?

  1. Write down both references and the edition. Read each complete paragraph or scene before quoting a single sentence.
  2. State the exact difference. Is it a count, timing, location, wording, speaker or assertion? Do not answer a location problem with a solution about numbers.
  3. Separate observation from reconstruction. “Mark names Bartimaeus” is in the passage. A proposed reason for selecting him is an inference.
  4. Identify the evidence a solution needs. A claim about manuscript copying requires textual witnesses; a claim about a word requires evidence about its use. Naming a category is not the same as demonstrating the explanation.
  5. Record the limit of the result. The conclusion may be a persuasive contextual reading, a possible reconciliation or an unresolved difference. Those are different outcomes.

Try the method with the Jericho passages. Mark separately what each account says about the people, their request, Jesus' response and movement relative to the city. Then explain which proposed answer addresses which difference. The goal is a conclusion another reader can inspect, including where the evidence runs out.

Sources and Further Reading

  • Primary comparison: Matthew 20:29–34; Mark 10:46–52; Luke 18:35–43; John 5:30–40; John 8:12–20; Deuteronomy 19:15–21; 2 Samuel 8:1–14; 1 Chronicles 18:1–13. Linked passages use the KJV; the comparisons and assessment of their limits are this site's own.
  • Further-reading recommendations: Alleged Discrepancies of the Bible and how to defend Scripture. The analysis above is based on the identified biblical passages.
  • The separate study of the four Gospels considers their arrangements and emphases. It does not replace a careful comparison of a disputed detail.
Recommended Articles




About the Bible Series