What Is Gnosticism?

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

Gnosticism is a modern umbrella term for several ancient religious teachings in which saving knowledge reveals humanity's relationship to a divine reality beyond the visible world. Many writings placed under this heading distinguish the highest God from a lower world-making power. They do not all tell the same story about creation, Jesus, salvation or the human body. A useful definition therefore needs named examples as well as a description of their similarities.

The name is connected with the Greek gnōsis, meaning knowledge or understanding. Knowing that meaning does not identify a particular ancient movement. The word also appears in ordinary and favorable religious settings; its use alone is not a test for “Gnosticism.” See the Greek dictionary entry for gnōsis.

Was There One Gnostic Religion?

The modern category is disputed. Michael Williams argues that it can impose a misleading unity on different ancient traditions. Other scholars continue to use the term while explaining its limits. Edward Moore and John Turner's introduction to the subject, for example, distinguishes the modern label from ancient uses of “gnostic” and stresses questions about the world's maker and saving insight.

For this guide, the term is a way to locate texts for comparison. It does not mean that everyone assigned to the category belonged to one organization, accepted one creed or used this name for themselves. “All Gnostics believed…” is usually a reason to ask which people and which evidence the writer means. The University of Washington's account of Williams's argument and the Cambridge chapter introduction give two identifiable scholarly starting points.

Two Texts Show Why the Differences Matter

The Apocryphon of John, also called the Secret Book of John, presents a revelation to John. In Frederik Wisse's translation, Sophia brings forth an imperfect being, Yaltabaoth, who becomes a ruler and produces subordinate powers. He claims to be the only God while remaining ignorant of his own origin. In the account of Adam, power from above animates the body, and a divine helper teaches him about his origin and ascent.

This is a specific reinterpretation of creation and the human predicament. Its hierarchy of powers should not be reduced to a claim that two equally powerful gods are fighting. Nor should the revelation's presentation as teaching to John be confused with proof that the apostle wrote it. Read the Wisse translation, especially the Sophia–Yaltabaoth episode and the animation of Adam, before turning this example into a general definition.

The Gospel of Truth uses a different emphasis. Its opening describes ignorance of the Father producing fear and error; the Savior makes the Father known. It speaks of Jesus being nailed to a tree, and later compares ignorance disappearing before knowledge with darkness disappearing before light. In the passages compared here, it does not give the Secret Book of John's sequence of named rulers.

Both works connect salvation with revelation and knowledge, but their actual presentations differ. The Gospel of Truth also speaks of grace, a divine calling and responding to the caller. Describing its message merely as “learning a password” would miss those features. Consult the translation by Harold W. Attridge and George W. MacRae, from the opening through the knowledge-and-light comparison. This comparison concerns these passages, rather than every teaching associated with either work.

What Can Irenaeus Tell Us?

Irenaeus wrote Against Heresies around AD 180. In Book I's preface, he says he has read writings and spoken with people associated with Valentinus's followers. He identifies the disciples of Ptolemy as a particular concern. He also openly states that he wants to refute their teaching.

His evidence is valuable, but it is an opponent's account written for an argument. In Book I, chapter 5, he reports a creator ignorant of a higher source and distinguishes material, psychic and spiritual elements. Those details should be attributed to the teaching he is reporting, rather than assigned to everyone called Gnostic. His report also distinguishes the creator from the devil; a summary that calls every lower creator simply “Satan” would erase a distinction in this source.

Read the report beside the ancient writings themselves. Agreement may help identify a shared issue; disagreement may reflect different schools, different texts or the purposes of the reporting author. A polemical source should neither be discarded automatically nor treated as a neutral transcript of every opponent's beliefs.

When Did These Teachings Begin?

The second century AD supplies important evidence, including Irenaeus's discussion of named teachers and schools. That gives a firmer historical starting point than an unsupported claim that one Gnostic religion began in a particular century of ancient Greece. The dates, development and relationships of individual writings require separate investigation. The comparison above does not establish a single founder or starting year for everything now placed under the label.

Is 1 Timothy 6:20 Naming Gnosticism?

The KJV warns Timothy against “science falsely so called” in 1 Timothy 6:20. Here the underlying word is gnōsis, knowledge. Read verses 17–21 together: instructions about wealth and generosity lead into a charge to guard what has been entrusted to Timothy and avoid claims that lead people away from faith. The warning does not name Valentinus, Ptolemy or the two writings compared above. The occurrence of the word “knowledge” cannot by itself identify those later historical examples.

A Christian assessment should compare particular claims with particular passages. Genesis 1:26–31 describes God's creation and its goodness. John 1:1–18 connects creation with the Word and says that the Word became flesh. These are concrete passages to place beside a text's account of the world's maker and of Jesus. Calling a teaching false and establishing what its adherents actually taught are related tasks that each need evidence. The site's guide to heresy explains how to identify a doctrinal judgment and its standard.

A Practical Reading Method

  1. Name the work and translation. Start with one passage, rather than a list of supposed universal Gnostic beliefs.
  2. Write down its actors. Who is the highest divine reality? Who makes the world? What is wrong with the human condition?
  3. Follow its account of rescue. Notice revelation, grace, knowledge, conduct and the role assigned to Jesus, wherever the passage discusses them.
  4. Keep witnesses distinct. Mark an opponent's report as a report, and check it against the relevant writing when one survives.
  5. Separate conclusions. First state what the source says; then explain the historical classification or Christian evaluation you draw from it.

For other vocabulary, return to the dictionary of Christian terms. A collection label such as Apocrypha concerns another question: a book's placement and authority in a named collection. It is not a synonym for Gnosticism.

The linked ancient translations and the identified scholarly introductions support this limited comparison. The modern books and full Cambridge chapter have not been reviewed here in their entirety. Bible passages were read in the King James Version.

Recommended Articles