Engedi: Read the Wilderness, Vineyard and Vision Separately
Engedi appears in a city list, a narrative about David and Saul, poetry and Ezekiel’s vision. The repeated name provides a link, but each passage uses it for a different purpose. A vision of fishing is not a report of an event during David’s life.
What Does the Name Identify?
The Hebrew עֵין גֶּדִי, Engedi or En-gedi (H5872), is explained as “spring of a kid,” meaning a young goat. The NAS concordance places it on the western shore of the Dead Sea. This broad setting is sufficient for the passages below; identifying a particular surviving cave would need further evidence.
Compare the References
| Passage | Setting | What to distinguish |
|---|---|---|
| Joshua 15:61–63 | Allotment list | Engedi occurs among Judah’s wilderness towns. |
| 1 Samuel 23:29–24:22 | David and Saul narrative | David reaches the strongholds; Saul searches for him, and the cave encounter follows. |
| 2 Chronicles 20:1–17 | Report to Jehoshaphat | The approaching enemy is reported at Hazazon-tamar, explicitly identified as Engedi. |
| Song of Solomon 1:12–17; Ezekiel 47:1–12 | Poetry and vision | Vineyard imagery and future fishing describe distinct literary settings. |
What Happens in the Cave Account?
Saul goes into a cave while David and his men are farther inside. David cuts a piece of Saul’s robe but restrains his followers from attacking him. After Saul leaves, David shows the cloth as evidence that he has spared the king. Their exchange concerns loyalty, danger and judgment; the narrative does not name a particular cave that visitors can identify today.
Where Does the Hazazon-tamar Identification Come From?
Second Chronicles 20:2 explicitly adds “which is Engedi” to Hazazon-tamar. Genesis 14:7 names Hazezon-tamar among the places attacked by Chedorlaomer’s coalition, but does not itself add the name Engedi. State the identification from Chronicles as such rather than inserting “Engedi” into a quotation from Genesis. Jehoshaphat then prays at Jerusalem; the report of the enemy’s location is not the location of that prayer.
Why Compare the Vineyard and Fishing References?
Song of Solomon 1:14 uses the vineyards of Engedi in a comparison about the beloved. Ezekiel 47:10 describes fishers from Engedi to Eneglaim within the vision of waters flowing from the sanctuary. Keeping poem and vision distinct helps explain why both mention the place without turning either into an archaeological description of a single historical scene. For another explicitly named refuge used by David, compare Adullam.
Sources and Reading Limits
The comparisons above are independently written from the KJV passages linked here. Lexical references supply names, proposed derivations and distinctions; their modern location conjectures and later topical commentary are not used to establish dates or sites.