Adullam: Distinguish the City and Cave Accounts

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

Adullam names a Canaanite city and the cave associated with David’s followers. The city list, the flight from Saul and the account of three warriors bringing water answer different questions. They should not be turned into one continuous episode.

What Does the Name Identify?

The Hebrew name עֲדֻלָּם, Adullam, is indexed as H5725. Strong’s proposes a derivation, while the NAS concordance traces it to an unused word. Neither gives a secure basis for treating “justice of the people” as a meaning explained by the biblical narrative. The place and its actions are clearer than that traditional gloss.

Compare the References

Read the action as well as the place name
Passage Setting What to distinguish
Joshua 12:15; 15:35 City A defeated king appears in the conquest list; Adullam later appears among towns in the valley section of Judah’s list.
1 Samuel 22:1–5 Refuge and followers David escapes to the cave, his family joins him, and distressed people gather around him.
2 Samuel 23:13–17; 1 Chronicles 11:15–19 Water from Bethlehem Three warriors come to David at Adullam and risk their lives to bring water from Bethlehem.

Who Joins David at the Cave?

In 1 Samuel 22, Adullam is more than an empty hiding place. David’s family comes down to him; people in distress, debt or discontent gather, and he becomes captain over about four hundred men. The account then moves to Moab and the prophet Gad’s instruction to enter Judah. Its movements do not establish an exact length of stay at the cave.

Why Does David Refuse the Water?

The later warrior account places the Philistines in the valley of Rephaim and a garrison at Bethlehem. David longs for water from Bethlehem’s well. Three men obtain it, but he pours it out to the Lord because of the danger they faced. The point is the cost of their loyalty, rather than the discovery of a new water source. The Bethlehem entry treats the town’s connection with David.

Is Every Reference to “the Hold” Adullam?

Second Samuel 5:17 says that David goes down to “the hold” when the Philistines hear he has been anointed king over Israel. That verse does not name Adullam. Second Samuel 23 does name the cave, but the shared word “hold” alone does not prove that the two scenes have the same location or date. Read the explicit place name before filling a gap from another chapter.

Sources and Reading Limits

The comparisons above are independently written from the KJV passages linked here. Lexical references supply names, proposed derivations and distinctions; their modern location conjectures and later topical commentary are not used to establish dates or sites.