Why Did David Wait to Be King?

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

David was anointed before he became the reigning king, and he became king over Judah before he ruled all Israel. Saul remained on the throne after Samuel anointed David. David refused opportunities to kill Saul, and after Saul's death there was still a rival kingdom under Saul's son. These events explain the stages of David's wait. The text does not give his age at Samuel's anointing or disclose a complete account of God's reasons for the timing.

What Were the Stages of David's Rise?

In 1 Samuel 16, God sends Samuel to Jesse's household because he has provided a king among Jesse's sons. David is the youngest and is away keeping sheep. When he arrives, God tells Samuel to anoint him. The Spirit of the Lord comes upon David from that day forward (16:1–13).

This act identifies God's chosen king, but it does not immediately place David on Saul's throne. The same chapter describes David coming into Saul's service as a musician and armor bearer (16:14–23).

Three anointings in different circumstances
Passage What happens? David's position
1 Samuel 16:1–13 Samuel anoints David at God's direction. Chosen for kingship while Saul is still reigning.
2 Samuel 2:1–11 After Saul's death, David goes to Hebron at God's direction, and the men of Judah anoint him. King over the house of Judah; Saul's son Ish-bosheth rules a rival kingdom.
2 Samuel 5:1–5 The elders of Israel make a covenant with David before the Lord and anoint him. King over Israel, following his period of rule over Judah.

Why Did He Refuse to Kill Saul?

David's restraint is explicit. In 1 Samuel 24, Saul pursues him, enters a cave where David and his men are hiding, and leaves without knowing how vulnerable he has been. David's men regard the moment as an opportunity, but David refuses to attack “the LORD's anointed” (24:6). He even feels remorse for cutting off a piece of Saul's robe.

David later tells Saul, “The LORD judge between me and thee,” adding, “but mine hand shall not be upon thee” (24:12). He entrusts his vindication to God rather than making the opportunity to kill Saul the means of taking the kingdom.

A similar choice appears in 1 Samuel 26. Abishai offers to kill Saul as he sleeps, but David stops him. David says that the Lord may strike Saul, that his day may come to die, or that he may perish in battle (26:9–11). His point is that he will not strike the Lord's anointed himself. These are David's stated reasons for restraint, rather than a prediction of a fixed number of years he must wait.

Saul dies in the battle described in 1 Samuel 31. When David receives news of Saul and Jonathan, he mourns and fasts; his lament honors them rather than celebrating a cleared path to the throne (2 Samuel 1).

Why Did All Israel Not Follow Him Immediately?

After David is made king over Judah, Abner establishes Saul's son Ish-bosheth as king over other parts of Israel (2 Samuel 2:8–11). Thus Saul's death does not immediately produce one united kingdom under David. Second Samuel 3:1 describes a long war between the house of Saul and the house of David, with David's house growing stronger.

Abner later negotiates with David and speaks with Israel's elders about bringing the kingdom under him (3:6–21). Second Samuel 4 opens with the news of Abner's death weakening Ish-bosheth. When two men then murder Ish-bosheth and bring his head to David, David condemns the killing and orders their punishment. He does not reward murder as service to his claim.

In 2 Samuel 5:1–3, Israel's tribes and elders come to David at Hebron. They recognize their kinship with him, his earlier leadership even under Saul, and the Lord's word concerning his leadership. David makes a covenant with them before the Lord, and they anoint him king over Israel.

How Long Did David Wait?

Second Samuel 5:4 says David was thirty when he began to reign. Verse 5 distinguishes seven years and six months reigning over Judah in Hebron from thirty-three years in Jerusalem over all Israel and Judah. The seven years and six months in Hebron are also stated in 2 Samuel 2:11.

Samuel's first anointing account does not state David's age. Consequently, subtracting an assumed age of ten or fifteen from thirty does not establish a biblical waiting period. We can state the period of his rule over Judah before his rule over all Israel, but cannot calculate the exact interval from Samuel's anointing to his first accession.

The text also summarizes his reign as forty years (2 Samuel 5:4), while its two stated periods add to forty years and six months. These figures should be reported as given. They do not justify an exact reconstruction of every birthday or the rounding used in the summary.

Was the Delay Punishment or Preparation?

These accounts do not attribute the delay to the sins of David's ancestors. They describe God's choice, Saul's continuing reign, David's restraint and the divided allegiance after Saul's death. A claim that an ancestral curse fixed David's waiting period would need evidence the narrative does not provide.

David's experiences reveal courage, restraint and dependence on God, and readers can reflect on them as occasions of preparation. But saying that God delayed the throne for exactly fifteen years until David had passed a specified test goes beyond what is stated. The Lord's words about looking on the heart in 1 Samuel 16:7 explain Samuel's choice among Jesse's sons; they do not supply a timetable for accession.

When David's kingdom is established, 2 Samuel 5:12 says that he recognizes the Lord's action and that his kingdom has been exalted for the sake of God's people Israel. That stated purpose keeps the focus on serving the people, while leaving unrecorded explanations of the timing unclaimed.

Sources and Related Reading

Prepared by LetsLearnTheBible.com. Short quotations follow the King James Version. The recorded stages and dates are distinguished from proposed ages and explanations of God's unrecorded purposes.