Who Were the Twelve Apostles?

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

The Twelve were the group Jesus chose from among his disciples and appointed as apostles. Their names appear in Matthew 10, Mark 3 and Luke 6. After Judas Iscariot's departure and death, Matthias was numbered with the eleven in Acts 1. That replacement does not mean Jesus originally selected thirteen.

What Are Their Names?

The following list follows Matthew 10:2–4 in the King James Version. Mark and Luke arrange some names differently. Their order is not a timetable of when each man first met Jesus.

The original Twelve in Matthew 10:2–4
Name in Matthew Identification or comparison
Simon Peter Simon, called Peter; Andrew's brother. Mark also says Jesus named him Peter.
Andrew Peter's brother.
James, son of Zebedee John's brother; distinct from James, son of Alphaeus.
John Brother of James, son of Zebedee.
Philip Also named in Mark and Luke.
Bartholomew Also named in Mark and Luke.
Thomas John 20:24 also calls him Didymus.
Matthew Matthew's list calls him “the publican,” or tax collector.
James, son of Alphaeus The second James in the list, distinguished by his father's name.
Lebbaeus, surnamed Thaddaeus Mark has Thaddaeus; Luke has Judas “the brother of James” in the KJV at the corresponding place among the remaining names.
Simon the Canaanite Mark uses the same designation; Luke's corresponding Simon is called Zelotes.
Judas Iscariot All three lists identify him as the betrayer.

Why Do the Lists Differ?

Some repeated names are explicitly distinguished. Matthew identifies two men named James by their fathers, Zebedee and Alphaeus, and distinguishes Simon Peter from Simon the Canaanite. Luke names Judas in relation to James and then Judas Iscariot. John 14:22 is especially direct: “Judas saith unto him, not Iscariot.” Readers should not merge these men merely because they share a name.

Comparing the complete lists leads to the common identification of Matthew's Lebbaeus/Thaddaeus and Mark's Thaddaeus with Luke's Judas associated with James. The lists themselves do not include a sentence explicitly stating that all these names belong to one man. The correspondence is a comparison of the lists and should be described that way. Likewise, the Simon called Canaanite in Matthew and Mark corresponds to Simon called Zelotes in Luke and Acts.

Bartholomew is often identified with Nathanael, whom Philip brings to Jesus in John 1:45–51. However, that passage never calls Nathanael Bartholomew. It is useful to know the proposed identification without presenting it as John's explicit wording. Nor do the lists establish that Simon and the Judas associated with James were brothers of James, son of Alphaeus. The KJV's wording about Judas and James does not supply that entire family tree.

Why Did Jesus Choose Them?

Luke 6:12–16 places the choice after a night Jesus spent praying to God. Jesus called his disciples and “of them he chose twelve, whom also he named apostles.” The passage therefore distinguishes the wider body of disciples from the twelve selected from it.

Mark 3:13–19 says Jesus appointed the Twelve “that they should be with him, and that he might send them forth to preach,” with authority over sickness and demons. Matthew 10:1–8 describes an initial sending to the lost sheep of the house of Israel, to preach that the kingdom of heaven was at hand and to heal. These texts explain their calling through their relationship to Jesus and the work he entrusted to them.

Being one of the Twelve did not guarantee faithfulness. In John 6:60–71 many disciples withdraw; Jesus addresses the Twelve, and Peter confesses that Jesus has the words of eternal life. The passage nevertheless identifies Judas Iscariot as one of that chosen group and as the future betrayer.

What About Matthias and Paul?

Acts 1:12–26 first lists eleven apostles without Judas Iscariot. Peter then explains that someone must take Judas's place in the ministry. The proposed witness must have accompanied them during Jesus' ministry, from John's baptism to the ascension, and become a witness of his resurrection with them. Joseph called Barsabas and Matthias are put forward; after prayer and the casting of lots, Matthias is “numbered with the eleven apostles.”

Thus, twelve men belonged to the original group, and another man later took Judas's place. Counting thirteen individuals across those two stages is possible, but saying “there were not twelve apostles” obscures the Gospel accounts and the reason for the replacement.

Paul was also an apostle, but the Acts 1 account names Matthias as the replacement. In 1 Corinthians 15:1–11 Paul recounts appearances of the risen Christ to Cephas, the Twelve, other witnesses and finally himself. He explicitly calls himself an apostle while distinguishing his own experience from the earlier appearances. “Apostle” therefore is not confined to the original twelve names, and Paul need not be inserted into their original list to affirm his apostleship.

What Can We Say About Their Lives?

The passages provide unequal amounts of personal detail. John 1 explicitly names Andrew as one of two disciples who first follow Jesus in that scene, but leaves the other unnamed. It then describes Andrew bringing Simon and Philip finding Nathanael. That account cannot establish a complete calling order for all twelve men.

Thomas's reluctance to believe the resurrection report, and his eventual confession “My Lord and my God,” are recorded in John 20:19–29. That is the direct source for this episode. The apostolic name lists themselves do not give each man's later mission destinations, writing dates, burial place or manner of death. Such details need their own evidence; they should not be supplied as though every one were part of the Gospel lists.

Sources and Related Reading

Prepared by LetsLearnTheBible.com. Short quotations and the displayed apostle list follow the King James Version. Correspondences between differing names are distinguished from explicit identifications.