Should Wives Be Submissive?
The New Testament does tell wives to submit to their own husbands (Ephesians 5:22; Colossians 3:18; 1 Peter 3:1). A faithful answer must also read the surrounding instructions: mutual submission in reverence for God, husbands' self-giving love, honor toward wives as fellow heirs, and compassion toward one another. Christians disagree about how marital roles should work today. These texts do not give a husband permission to enforce submission by threats, violence or sexual coercion.
Begin Before Ephesians 5:22
Ephesians 5 begins with a call to imitate God and walk in love, following Christ's self-giving example (5:1–2). It rejects sexual wrongdoing and greed, calls believers to live in the light, and urges wise, Spirit-filled living (5:3–20). Verse 21 then says:
“Submitting yourselves one to another in the fear of God.” — Ephesians 5:21, KJV
The instructions to wives and husbands follow within that setting. Paul describes the husband as the wife's head, compares marriage with Christ and the church, and tells wives to submit to their own husbands (5:22–24). Those are real features of the passage and should not be silently removed. Equally, the passage is not a detached rule giving every man authority over every woman. It addresses a particular marriage relationship within life under Christ.
The words “as unto the Lord” and “in every thing” must be read alongside the chapter's rejection of evil and its demand for love. They cannot make a husband morally infallible or turn a sinful demand into the Lord's will. Colossians 3:18 similarly qualifies submission as “fit in the Lord.” A wife's allegiance to God is not transferred to her husband.
Read the Husband's Instructions at Full Strength
Paul tells husbands to love their wives as Christ loved the church and gave himself for it (Ephesians 5:25). He then compares this care to nourishing and cherishing one's own body (5:28–29), recalls the one-flesh union of Genesis, and concludes with love and respect (5:31–33). A husband who uses the passage to obtain service while avoiding its costly demands on himself has misread its direction.
The comparison with Christ does not make the husband his wife's savior. Paul says he is speaking about Christ and the church (5:32). A husband cannot cleanse away his wife's sins, replace Christ as her Lord or claim that disagreement with him is automatically rejection of God.
Colossians pairs its instruction to wives with “Husbands, love your wives, and be not bitter against them” (3:19). The wider household instructions also hold people with power accountable to their heavenly Master (3:18–4:1; compare Ephesians 6:1–9). The ancient household setting deserves attention; it is not a blank check for present-day control.
| Text | Instruction | A misuse to reject |
|---|---|---|
| Ephesians 5:21–24 | Mutual submission provides the setting for the words to wives. | Treating a husband's preference as God's unrestricted command. |
| Ephesians 5:25–33 | Husbands must practice sacrificial love, nourishment and care. | Demanding deference while excusing cruelty or selfishness. |
| Colossians 3:18–19 | Submission is in the Lord; husbands must love without bitterness. | Separating the wife's responsibility from the husband's accountability. |
| 1 Peter 3:1–7 | Faithful conduct matters; husbands must honor wives as fellow heirs. | Calling a wife spiritually inferior or promising submission will convert her husband. |
Why Do Christians Reach Different Conclusions?
One reading understands headship and submission as continuing, distinct responsibilities: a husband exercises leadership through sacrificial service, and a wife willingly supports that leadership. Another reading places greater emphasis on mutual submission, shared authority and the way the gospel reshapes the household patterns being addressed. Both readings must explain the specific words to wives and the surrounding commands, rather than quoting only the lines most convenient to their conclusion.
This disagreement should be named honestly instead of presenting one arrangement for every decision as the only undisputed Christian position. The passage does not provide a household rulebook assigning every financial, employment, educational or domestic decision to one spouse. Applying it requires wisdom about the actual people and responsibilities involved.
What About an Unbelieving or Unkind Husband?
First Peter addresses believers living as strangers among others, urges honorable conduct, and discusses suffering unjustly with Christ's nonretaliatory example in view (2:11–25). It then speaks to wives whose husbands may disobey the word. Their conduct may win those husbands “without the word” (3:1–2). In the KJV, “conversation” here means conduct. Peter is describing the influence of a faithful life, not prohibiting every conversation about faith or guaranteeing conversion.
His emphasis on the inward person and a gentle spirit (3:3–4) does not mean a wife must have no opinions or never speak about harm. His reference to Sarah includes doing good without being frightened by terror (3:5–6). Verse 7 then requires husbands to live considerately, honor their wives and recognize them as “heirs together of the grace of life.” The phrase “weaker vessel” does not make wives less valuable or less entitled to that inheritance. It strengthens the demand for care rather than excusing domination; Peter warns that husbands' prayers can be hindered.
The discussion of suffering is morally serious, but honoring endurance does not authorize the person causing suffering. It is a misuse to turn Christ's example into an order that a wife conceal violence, surrender access to help or remain within an abuser's reach. The passage proceeds to compassion, refusal of retaliation, doing good and seeking peace (3:8–17).
What Can This Mean in Daily Married Life?
A constructive application begins with each spouse's responsibilities: listen carefully, speak without contempt, share necessary information, recognize each other's abilities and discuss decisions affecting both. Respect includes hearing a genuine disagreement. A wife can question a proposal, refuse wrongdoing and seek advice. A husband can serve his wife without turning his service into a demand for compliance.
No marital role permits assault, forced sex, threats, confinement or withholding access to protection. The person using violence is responsible for that violence; a wife's failure to agree is not its cause. If you or your children face immediate danger, contact local emergency services. Specialist domestic-abuse services or a qualified professional can help you consider safety and support. An online article cannot decide your legal options or the outcome of your marriage.
For ordinary disagreements in a safe relationship, a mutually chosen counselor or trusted pastor may help both spouses listen and take responsibility. That is different from promising that better communication or greater submission will stop abuse. The teaching's demand for love, honor and accountability must remain visible wherever its words about submission are used.
Sources and Related Studies
Primary passages read in the public-domain King James Version: Ephesians 5:1–6:9; Colossians 3:18–4:1; 1 Peter 2–3; Genesis 2:18–25. The two broad readings above summarize an interpretive disagreement; they are not claims that Scripture specifies a modern decision-making procedure.