Should Christians Try to Cast Out Demons? Authority and Caution in Scripture

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

The New Testament presents Jesus as having authority over unclean spirits and describes him giving authority to people he sends. Those accounts do not support treating his name as a formula that anyone can use to guarantee a result. They also do not supply a test by which a reader can identify another person's present distress as demonic.

Christians differ over how the particular missions and gifts described in these passages apply to ministry today. A sound answer must distinguish those interpretive questions from what the accounts actually narrate. It should also keep the welfare of a person seeking help at the center.

Who received authority from Jesus?

Matthew 10:1 introduces a deliberate act: Jesus calls his twelve disciples and gives them authority over unclean spirits and diseases. The chapter names them and describes their mission. Its initial instructions direct them to the lost sheep of Israel rather than to Gentile or Samaritan towns (Matthew 10:2–8). Luke 9:1–6 likewise links authority with Jesus' sending the Twelve to proclaim God's kingdom and heal.

The audience and setting matter. These are commissions to identifiable people with particular instructions. A reader should explain any move from that mission to a universal rule for every Christian, rather than simply assume it.

Authority is also exercised beyond the Twelve. Luke 10 describes another group appointed and sent ahead of Jesus. The KJV calls them seventy. They return rejoicing that demons submit to them through his name. Jesus acknowledges their experience but directs their joy toward their names being written in heaven (Luke 10:1–20). The story gives neither personal power nor spectacular results the final emphasis.

These accounts therefore show both real delegation and dependence on the sender. They do not make a person's confidence a substitute for Jesus' authority. Nor does the fact that two groups are sent settle every question about the scope of later Christian ministry.

Why did the disciples fail with the boy?

In Mark 9:14–29, Jesus returns to a dispute involving the disciples, scribes and a crowd. A father explains his son's suffering and the disciples' inability to help. His appeal asks for compassion. Jesus delivers the boy, then privately answers the disciples' question about their failure.

Matthew 17:14–21 reports the corresponding encounter and emphasizes their unbelief in Jesus' answer. In the KJV, Matthew 17:21 and Mark 9:29 also speak of prayer and fasting. Read within the narratives, the emphasis calls the disciples away from self-sufficiency toward dependence on God. It does not give readers a timetable, a required level of intensity or a guaranteed method.

The rebuke must not be transferred carelessly to the father or the child. Mark gives the father a candid appeal for help with his unbelief, and Jesus helps his son. The account does not instruct a modern reader to blame a suffering person when a prayer appears unanswered. In Luke's version, Jesus heals the child and gives him back to his father; the crowd is amazed at God's greatness (Luke 9:37–43).

The surrounding chapters also correct the disciples' preoccupation with status. Mark 9 continues from their failure to their argument over greatness and Jesus' teaching about service (verses 33–37). Their delegated mission does not make them independent of him or turn vulnerability into an occasion for proving their importance.

What about the man outside their group?

John reports that the disciples tried to stop a man casting out demons in Jesus' name because he was not following their group. Jesus tells them not to stop him (Mark 9:38–40; Luke 9:49–50). This prevents an overstatement sometimes drawn from the earlier commissions: the narratives do not confine all effective ministry to the Twelve alone.

At the same time, this incident concerns a particular man whose activity Jesus addresses. It is not a declaration that every claim to act in his name is valid. Read beside Acts 19, it challenges both group possessiveness and the assumption that invoking a name automatically supplies authority.

What went wrong in Acts 19?

Acts 19:11 explicitly attributes extraordinary miracles through Paul to God. The following episode describes traveling exorcists attempting to invoke Jesus, whom Paul preaches. Seven sons of Sceva are associated with that attempt. The evil spirit challenges them, and the man attacks and injures them (Acts 19:13–16).

The text does not give a detailed account of the brothers' private thoughts. Their family description does not establish that they felt powerful because of their ancestry. The narrated contrast is sufficient: God's work through Paul is followed by an unsuccessful attempt to appropriate the name associated with that work.

The aftermath matters too. Fear spreads, Jesus' name is honored, people confess their practices and some give up books connected with magic. Luke closes this section by describing the growth of the Lord's word (Acts 19:17–20). The outcome is not a lesson in how to repeat a confrontation more effectively; it is a warning against trying to use Jesus' name as an instrument of control.

Read the accounts together
Account What the text shows What should not be assumed
Matthew 10:1–8; Luke 9:1–6 Jesus gives authority to the Twelve for their mission. Every mission instruction transfers unchanged to every reader.
Luke 10:1–20 A wider appointed group reports deliverance through his name. Spiritual power is the proper basis of personal status.
Mark 9:14–29; Matthew 17:14–21 The disciples fail; Jesus helps the child and corrects them. The narrative is a guaranteed procedure or grounds for blaming a sufferer.
Mark 9:38–40; Luke 9:49–50 Jesus accepts ministry beyond the disciples' immediate group. Group membership alone settles authority.
Acts 19:11–20 God's work through Paul contrasts with misuse of Jesus' name. The name can be borrowed as a formula.

What follows for Christians today?

One approach reads the missions as a pattern for continuing deliverance ministry; another stresses their particular setting and rejects a general commission to perform exorcisms. This study does not pretend those readings are identical or that all Christians have agreed on one. Both must answer to the accounts' emphasis on Christ, dependence on God and the danger of presumption.

First Corinthians 12 provides another relevant limit: the same Spirit distributes different gifts, and Paul does not treat every member as having the same work (verses 4–11, 27–30). That chapter is not a detailed policy for exorcism. It does challenge an argument that every believer must display an identical extraordinary ability as proof of faith.

For a reader faced with someone's fear or distress, these texts do not establish a diagnosis. They should not be turned into a reason to label a person possessed, restrain or pressure them, or interfere with their care. Prayer and responsible pastoral support can be offered without claiming certainty about an unseen cause. If someone faces immediate danger, protect the person and seek appropriate urgent help.

For concerns about a home, Worried About Evil Spirits in Your Home? considers a careful response. The question of what “ghost” means belongs to the separate study What Does the Bible Say About Ghosts? Neither question should be settled by treating every frightening experience as the same event.

What is the article's conclusion?

Jesus' authority is central; the reader's ability to manufacture a result is not. Scripture describes commissions, failures, ministry outside the Twelve's group and a dangerous misuse of Jesus' name. Taken together, those passages rule out an automatic formula and call for humility about claims of personal authority.

A Christian can pray, care for a person and seek accountable support without staging a confrontation. Questions about present ministry should be discussed honestly within one's church tradition, while preserving the clear difference between reading a biblical deliverance account and knowing the cause of another person's experience today.

Sources and further reading

This study follows the KJV, including its wording about prayer and fasting in Matthew 17:21 and Mark 9:29. It interprets the narratives rather than offering a ritual or instructions for treating a person.