Which Old Testament Laws Apply to Christians? Covenants and Context

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

The New Testament neither treats Israel's law as worthless nor instructs Gentile believers simply to adopt every Mosaic requirement without distinction. It discusses fulfillment in Jesus, justification by grace through faith, the inclusion of Gentiles, Christ's priesthood and sacrifice, and a life shaped by love of God and neighbor. Those questions need to be distinguished before deciding how a particular command applies.

This guide addresses Christian interpretation. It does not describe Jewish Torah observance as an obsolete religious practice or offer a complete code for every Christian tradition. Where churches disagree, a conclusion needs an argument from the relevant passages rather than an assumption that one's own calendar or classification is shared by all.

Which Questions Should Be Separated?

A passage's subject determines the kind of answer it supplies
Question Passages to read What to distinguish
How are sinners justified? Romans 3:19–31; Galatians 2:15–21 Justification by God's grace through faith is not the same question as whether stealing is permitted.
Must Gentiles be circumcised and keep Moses' law? Acts 15:1–35; Galatians 5:1–14 The dispute concerns admission and obligation, not a denial that conduct matters.
Are repeated offerings needed to remove sins? Hebrews 7:11–28; 9:1–15; 10:1–18 Christ's priesthood and once-for-all offering are the argument's focus.
How should Christians treat others? Matthew 22:34–40; Romans 13:8–10; Galatians 5:13–14 Freedom is joined to love and service, rather than permission to harm.
How are disputed foods and days handled? Romans 14:1–23; Colossians 2:6–23 Conscience, mutual reception, judgment and the context of the observances all matter.

Does Jesus Dismiss the Law?

In Matthew 5:17–20, Jesus says he came to fulfill, not destroy, the Law and the Prophets. He speaks strongly about their significance, teaching and righteousness. A summary that says the Old Testament simply ceased to matter would miss the force of these words.

“Fulfill” also requires interpretation in relation to Jesus' work and the New Testament's covenant teaching. It cannot be treated as a shortcut that settles every later question about circumcision, sacrifice or a festival. Acts 15 and Hebrews address precisely such questions with their own arguments.

Romans 7:7–13 likewise calls the law holy, just and good while distinguishing the command from sin's misuse of it. The chapter's earlier verses also speak of dying to the law through Christ and serving in newness of the Spirit (7:4–6). Quoting only “holy, and just, and good” does not establish that every Israelite requirement operates unchanged for every Christian.

Ethical continuity is concrete. Jesus names love for God and neighbor as the two great commandments on which the Law and Prophets hang (Matthew 22:34–40). Romans 13:8–10 names prohibitions of adultery, murder, theft and coveting in its explanation of love. Leviticus 19:9–18 places care for the poor, honest dealing, fair judgment and love of neighbor among Israel's instructions. Calling such teaching “Old Testament” does not make injustice acceptable.

What Was Decided in Acts 15?

The dispute is explicit. Some teach that Gentile believers cannot be saved unless circumcised according to Moses' custom (15:1). Others say that the Gentiles must be circumcised and commanded to keep the law of Moses (15:5). Peter points to God's giving the Spirit and cleansing hearts by faith, and says that salvation is through the grace of the Lord Jesus (15:7–11).

The resulting letter addresses Gentile believers in Antioch, Syria and Cilicia. It rejects the unauthorized disturbance and names abstention from food offered to idols, blood, what is strangled, and sexual immorality (15:23–29). These instructions must remain in the discussion; Acts does not respond with “do whatever you wish.”

At the same time, the letter does not impose the proposed requirement of circumcision and keeping the whole Mosaic law. James' observation that Moses is read in synagogues every Sabbath (15:21) is part of his speech, not an explicit instruction in the letter that Gentiles must later enroll to acquire all the requirements initially withheld. That further reading needs to be argued rather than inserted as though the sentence says it.

Galatians sharpens the issue. Paul rejects justification by works of law (2:15–21), relates the law to the promise and coming of Christ (3:15–29), and warns those seeking justification through circumcision that this commits them to the whole law (5:1–6). He then insists that freedom must serve others through love (5:13–14). The rejection of one basis for justification is joined to a serious account of Christian conduct.

What Changes in Hebrews?

Hebrews 7 argues that Jesus' priesthood is not based on Levitical descent. Its statement that a change of priesthood entails a change of law belongs to that argument (7:11–19). Jesus lives permanently and intercedes, unlike priests whose service ends with death (7:23–28).

The argument continues beyond one verse. Hebrews 8:6–13 speaks of a better covenant and quotes the promise of God's laws written on hearts. Hebrews 9 contrasts the former sanctuary's rites with Christ's effective offering. Hebrews 10:1–18 contrasts repeated sacrifices, which cannot take sins away, with Christ's once-for-all offering. Where forgiveness is granted, it says, there is no further offering for sin (10:18).

These passages supply a direct Christian reason for not treating animal sin offerings as an additional means necessary to secure forgiveness. They do not merely say that modern people lack a convenient place to sacrifice. Nor does Hebrews 7:12, by itself, provide a numbered list deciding the contemporary application of every rule anywhere in Leviticus.

The book also should not be paraphrased as “all human priests are abolished,” as though that sentence alone resolved every church's understanding of ordained ministry. Its sustained claim concerns Christ's unique and effective high priesthood and sacrifice. Hebrews does not identify its author; Paul is not named here as its proven writer. The USCCB introduction explains the authorship question and the work's central argument.

Where Does the Threefold Classification Come From?

The distinction between moral, civil or judicial, and ceremonial laws is an influential Christian interpretive framework. The biblical books do not introduce every command under those three labels. Within Leviticus 19, for example, instructions about harvests, wages, courts and neighbor-love appear together. Classifying them already involves interpretation.

The Westminster Confession, chapter 19, gives a specific Reformed formulation: the moral law remains binding; ceremonial laws are abrogated under the New Testament; Israel's judicial laws have expired with that polity except insofar as their general equity requires. Its account also distinguishes the law's use as a guide from justification by it.

The Church of England's Article VII, “Of the Old Testament”, likewise distinguishes ceremonies and rites, civil precepts and commandments called moral. Those are attributable church statements. They should not be presented as a three-column classification explicitly supplied by Moses or as proof that every church classifies every disputed command alike.

The framework can help a reader formulate questions, but assigning a label does not replace reading a command's addressees, setting, purpose and treatment in the New Testament.

What about Sabbath, Food and Annual Festivals?

Exodus 20:8–11 explicitly commands Israel's seventh-day Sabbath, including rest for household members, workers, animals and the resident stranger. The command deserves to be read in full. Christians disagree over how this command relates to the new covenant, weekly worship and the Lord's Day.

For a clear example of a continuing seventh-day position, the official Seventh-day Adventist Sabbath statement calls seventh-day observance a requirement of the fourth commandment, a day of rest, worship and ministry. This source establishes that denomination's published position. It does not by itself establish that all Christians share it, or that annual festivals follow from the same argument.

Romans 14 addresses disagreements over eating and regarding days, urges reception rather than contempt, and warns against causing another to stumble. It does not name every disputed day or define every later calendar controversy. Colossians 2:16–17 explicitly names food, drink, festivals, new moons and Sabbaths in its warning against judgment and its contrast between shadow and Christ. The wider section also addresses imposed regulations and ascetic practices. A responsible study must engage these words rather than omit them from a claim of universal observance, while recognizing disagreement over the precise practices Paul opposes.

Prophetic visions need their own context. Isaiah 2:1–5 depicts nations coming to learn God's ways and the end of warfare. Zechariah 14:16–21 depicts survivors from the nations coming to worship the King and keep the Feast of Tabernacles, with consequences for refusal. It also speaks of holiness, pots and sacrifice. Those details should not be ignored. Moving from this vision to a rule that every present Christian must observe all annual festivals requires an explanation of the vision's fulfillment and its relation to the new covenant; the move is not stated directly in Acts 15.

Whether someone observes a particular festival is also not a reliable basis for a website to declare how many other Christians are truly converted. The passages deserve study without an unsupported judgment about other people's hearts.

How Can a Particular Command Be Studied?

  1. Read the whole instruction. Identify the addressee and the institutions it presupposes: a household, landholding, courts, sanctuary or priesthood.
  2. Identify the question being asked. Is it about justification, worship, civil enforcement, ethical conduct or voluntary observance?
  3. Trace the New Testament treatment. Look for direct instruction, fulfillment in Christ, use as an ethical example, or an explicit dispute.
  4. State the interpretive step. Explain why a command's principle, form or covenant obligation is being carried forward or understood differently.
  5. Name the position accurately. Distinguish a church's teaching from an interpretation shared by all Christians, and study conscientious disagreement without contempt.

For example, the continuing demand to love a neighbor can be supported by Matthew 22 and Romans 13, while the question of repeated sin offerings is answered through Hebrews' treatment of Christ. Neither question should be decided solely by attaching the same broad label, “Old Testament law.”

Sources and Further Study

Primary reading: Exodus 20:1–17; Leviticus 19:9–18; Isaiah 2:1–5; Zechariah 14:16–21; Matthew 5:17–20; 22:34–40; Acts 15:1–35; Romans 3:19–31; 7:1–13; 13:8–10; 14:1–23; Galatians 2:15–21; 3:15–29; 5:1–14; Hebrews 7:11–28; 8:6–13; 9:1–15; 10:1–18; Colossians 2:6–23. Wording was checked against the KJV. The church documents linked above are sources for the particular positions attributed to them, not replacements for those passages.

Continue with repentance, grace and changed conduct, the priesthood argument in Hebrews, teaching disciples to observe Jesus' commands and civil authority and taxes. See our editorial and correction policy.