Did David Fight Goliath and His Four Brothers?

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

David fought and killed Goliath in 1 Samuel 17. The Bible does not say he then fought four brothers of Goliath, or that his five stones were intended for five brothers. Later accounts describe other formidable Philistines defeated by David's men. One is explicitly identified in Chronicles as Goliath's brother, but the passages do not establish a family of five brothers.

Whom Did David Face?

First Samuel 17 introduces Goliath of Gath as the Philistine champion. He challenged Israel to send one man to fight him. Saul and the army were afraid, but David volunteered after hearing the challenge. David was tending his father's sheep and had come to bring supplies to his brothers serving with Saul (17:12–23, 32–37). He was not yet the king commanding the army in this scene.

The chapter describes Goliath's height, armor and weapons, presenting him as an intimidating opponent (17:4–7). Saul called David a youth; the narrative does not give David's exact age. It also does not introduce four brothers accompanying Goliath or preparing to fight David.

David rejected armor he had not proved, took his staff and sling, and selected five smooth stones from the brook. His speech to Goliath explains his confidence: he came in the name of the LORD, and “the battle is the LORD's” (17:45–47). When the fight began, he used a stone from his bag and struck Goliath in the forehead. He then took Goliath's sword and cut off his head; the Philistine army fled (17:48–53).

Why Five Stones?

First Samuel 17:40 states the number and describes the stones as smooth. It does not explain why David selected five. Verse 49 describes the stone he used against Goliath, without assigning the remaining stones to other opponents.

Suggestions that he wanted spare ammunition, expected several attempts, or knew about four brothers go beyond what the narrator tells us. They may sound plausible to different readers, but none is the stated reason. Nor does taking five stones demonstrate that David lacked faith: his own words explicitly express confidence in God. The passage allows us to say what he carried and whom he defeated while leaving his reason for that particular number unknown.

Who Killed the Later Giants?

Second Samuel 21:15–22 concerns later wars, rather than additional rounds of the encounter in 1 Samuel 17. David became exhausted during one battle and was threatened by Ishbi-benob. Abishai rescued him. Afterward David's men insisted that he no longer go out to battle with them.

The warriors named in 2 Samuel 21:15–22
Opponent Who defeated him? What the account says
Ishbi-benob Abishai He intended to kill the exhausted David.
Saph Sibbechai He was among the “sons of the giant.” Chronicles calls Sibbechai's opponent Sippai.
The opponent associated with Goliath Elhanan The parallel in 1 Chronicles 20:5 explicitly names Lahmi, Goliath's brother.
An unnamed man with six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot Jonathan, son of David's brother Shimea He defied Israel in a battle at Gath.

Samuel concludes that these four were born to the giant in Gath and fell by the hand of David and his servants (21:22). That collective summary should be read alongside the individual episodes, which name the men who killed them. It does not mean David personally killed each opponent. Nor does “sons of the giant” by itself identify all four as brothers of Goliath.

What About Elhanan and Goliath?

The wording at 2 Samuel 21:19 needs care when compared with 1 Chronicles 20:5. In the KJV, Samuel says Elhanan the son of Jaare-oregim, a Bethlehemite, killed “the brother of Goliath the Gittite.” Chronicles calls Elhanan the son of Jair and explicitly names his victim “Lahmi the brother of Goliath the Gittite.” The accounts do not use identical names and wording, and Samuel's KJV verse does not give the victim the name Lahmi.

Those differences should remain visible when comparing the passages, rather than quoting Chronicles' fuller identification as though it appeared identically in Samuel. This comparison reports the KJV wording; it does not establish how every difference between the texts arose. What Chronicles explicitly identifies is one brother of Goliath. Neither passage supplies a list of four brothers whom David anticipated when choosing his stones.

The answer therefore has three parts: David killed Goliath in the famous confrontation; David's warriors killed other giants in later battles; and the Bible leaves the reason for the five stones unstated.

Sources and Related Reading

Prepared by LetsLearnTheBible.com. Short quotations follow the King James Version.