Herod's Capture of Jerusalem

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

Herod received Roman recognition as king in 40 BCE, but he did not capture Jerusalem until 37 BCE. The difference explains why a man already called king still needed an army: the Roman decree gave him a claim backed by Roman power while Antigonus continued to hold Jerusalem. Appointment and possession were separate events.

Josephus describes the appointment in Antiquities of the Jews 14.14, the intervening campaigns in 14.15, and the siege and its aftermath in 14.16. Reading these chapters together prevents the conquest from becoming a simple story of a rightful ruler overcoming obstacles. They also disclose rival dynastic claims, the influence of money and military patrons, and severe harm to people inside the city.

How Could Herod Be King Before Taking Jerusalem?

In Josephus’s account, Herod reaches Rome after losing his position in Judea during the Parthian intervention. He appeals to Antony, and the discussion moves from personal assistance to the question of kingship. In 14.14.4, Antony argues that supporting Herod will serve Roman interests in the war with Parthia. The senate approves the appointment; 14.14.5 concludes with public honors and a celebration.

The “Caesar” acting with Antony in this scene is Octavian, the future Augustus. He is not Julius Caesar returned to the narrative. Josephus connects the support to earlier family relationships as well as to Roman policy and promised money. Those explanations describe the political machinery behind the appointment, rather than showing that all the inhabitants of Judea accepted it.

The conventional date for the appointment is 40 BCE. Josephus dates it through named Roman consuls in 14.14.5. His report of the capture in 14.16.4 names a different consular year, conventionally 37 BCE. The intervening chapter follows campaigns and changing alliances; it cannot be erased by treating “made king” as equivalent to “already governing Jerusalem.”

Which Passages Explain the Change of Power?

Roman recognition, military conquest, and the limits of each claim
Stage and passage Josephus's account Reading distinction
Appointment, 40 BCE: 14.14.3–5 Herod appeals to Antony; Roman leaders support him; the senate declares him king. Roman recognition explains the title. It does not establish control of the city, popular consent, or moral entitlement.
Campaigns: 14.15.1–3 Herod gathers forces and rescues his family. Antigonus challenges his claim; supplies and commanders' loyalty complicate the fighting. The conflict includes competing local interests and Roman interventions, rather than a single united population choosing one ruler.
Marriage: 14.15.14 With siege preparations underway, Herod goes to Samaria to marry Mariamne. A marriage into the Hasmonean family is part of the political setting; it does not settle the conflict with Antigonus.
Capture, 37 BCE: 14.16.1–2, 4 Herod and Sosius command the attacking forces; the defenses fall and the city suffers extensive killing. Military success supplies possession of Jerusalem. It does not convert the suffering into a justification of the victor.
Aftermath: 14.16.3–4 Herod restrains plunder and pays the soldiers; he also offers Antony money to have Antigonus killed. Read both episodes. The claim that Herod protected what remained of the city cannot erase his effort to eliminate a rival.

Josephus provides additional figures for the stages of the siege in 14.16.2 and attaches a fast-day comparison to the capture in 14.16.4. This guide does not convert those notices into an exact modern calendar date or assume that every chronological detail is independently settled. The main distinction is the three-year separation between Roman appointment and the capture conventionally dated to 37 BCE.

Was This Simply a Dispute About Royal Blood?

Antigonus belonged to the Hasmonean ruling family. In 14.15.2 he argues that, even if the Romans oppose him personally, another member of that family should receive the kingdom. Josephus also records an attack on Herod’s ancestry. These are arguments made within a struggle for power, not neutral rules that a modern guide should simply endorse.

Calling Herod a man with “no royal blood” loses important context. He was outside the Hasmonean dynasty by birth, but his marriage to Mariamne connected him to that family. Nor does a dynastic connection by itself answer who should govern. Josephus’s account brings together Roman military interests, family claims, money, and armed resistance; none can be substituted for an examination of the conduct of the rulers.

The source’s ancestry-based insults should therefore remain attributed to their speakers and setting. They do not provide a sound basis for judging the religious identity or worth of entire communities. Likewise, the Romans’ description of Antigonus as their enemy explains Roman policy; it does not resolve every question about his claim or the city’s resistance.

What Does Josephus Report About the Siege?

In 14.16.1, Josephus identifies two commanders: Sosius, sent by Antony, and Herod, seeking possession of the kingdom. The next section describes siege works, counterattacks, mining, hunger, and continued defense. It also records the defenders’ concern to maintain daily sacrifices after part of the temple area had fallen.

When the city is stormed, Josephus attributes the slaughter both to angry Roman soldiers and to Jewish forces supporting Herod. His account includes people killed in streets, houses, and places sought as refuge, with no protection for children or the aged. This is a civil conflict as well as an intervention by a foreign military power. Describing it as a clean transfer of kingship would conceal the passage’s central human cost.

Josephus praises the attackers’ military skill while using disparaging language about the defenders’ courage. Readers can identify that evaluation without repeating it as their own. The same passage reports that Herod called for the killing to stop, but that the soldiers continued. An order or appeal to stop violence is different from effective control of an army, and it does not undo the decision to take the city by force.

How Should Herod's Attempts at Protection Be Assessed?

In 14.16.3, Josephus portrays Herod restraining access to sacred things and objecting to the destruction of the population and city he intended to rule. Herod promises payment to the soldiers in place of further plunder. These actions belong in the account, but they should be read with the final section rather than made into a general verdict on his character.

In 14.16.4, Antigonus is taken to Antony. Josephus then reports Herod’s fear that his rival might obtain a hearing at Rome and revive the Hasmonean dynastic claim. Herod offers money to secure Antigonus’s death. Josephus closes by reflecting on the end of Hasmonean government and its internal divisions.

The paired episodes resist a one-word moral portrait. The narrator depicts Herod protecting the surviving city while also seeking the removal of a political rival through execution. A careful reading asks what each action achieves, whose interests it serves, and what the narrator chooses to emphasize. It does not turn success in obtaining power into proof that the power was deserved.

Questions for a Careful Reading

  1. Compare 14.14.4–5 with 14.16.1. What did the senate provide that still required a military campaign to enforce?
  2. List the reasons for supporting Herod given in 14.14.4. Which concern Roman policy, personal relationships, or money?
  3. Read Antigonus’s argument in 14.15.2 beside the marriage in 14.15.14. Why is “royal blood” an incomplete explanation of the conflict?
  4. In 14.16.2, distinguish Josephus’s account of events from his judgments about the defenders. How does his wording direct sympathy?
  5. Read 14.16.3 and 14.16.4 without stopping between them. How does the request to kill Antigonus complicate the preceding account of restraint?

Related Reading

For another account connecting an imperial ruler with Jerusalem, read Alexander at Jerusalem: Josephus’s account and its limits. The later building project has a separate guide: Herod’s rebuilding of the temple.

Sources and Method

This is an original reading guide to an ancient historical account. Its political and moral questions are editorial analysis, not additional ancient testimony. The appointment and capture dates summarize the conventional chronology; the guide makes no claim to resolve all detailed chronological problems. Sources consulted November 4, 2026.