Who Were the Pharisees? Beliefs, Traditions and Encounters with Jesus

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

The Pharisees were a Jewish group concerned with interpreting and practicing the law, including inherited traditions about its observance. The New Testament associates them with belief in resurrection and records disputes involving Jesus, his disciples and the early church. It also names Pharisees who question a judgment, urge restraint or become believers. Their name should therefore introduce a historical inquiry, rather than serve as a synonym for hypocrisy.

Name, Origins and Influence

The Greek name is Pharisaios. The G5330 lexical entry connects it with a word for separation. That helps explain a traditional understanding of the name; it does not establish one exact founding year, everything from which members separated, or an unbroken organization reaching back to Ezra.

Josephus places Pharisees in his account of the Hasmonean period. In Antiquities 13.10.5–6, he recounts a dispute involving John Hyrcanus and contrasts Pharisaic support among the multitude with Sadducean influence among the wealthy. In 18.1.3–4, he again describes their influence over religious practice and the constraints popular opinion placed on Sadducean officeholders. These are Josephus's descriptions, shaped by his interests and setting; they are not a census of every town or a constitution giving Pharisees control of every synagogue.

Matthew 23:2 says that the scribes and Pharisees sit in “Moses' seat.” The passage concerns teaching authority and the gap between instruction and conduct. It does not enumerate their public offices. The USCCB notes on Matthew 23:2–3 discuss both the figurative teaching sense and the question of actual synagogue seating. Later archaeological evidence does not by itself establish a uniform first-century system.

Written Law and Inherited Traditions

Josephus says that Pharisees transmitted observances inherited from their fathers that were not written in the laws of Moses, whereas Sadducees rejected the obligation to observe those inherited rules (Antiquities 13.10.6). The distinction concerns how the law was interpreted and made binding. It is too crude to describe one group as possessing scripture and the other as replacing it entirely with invented rules.

Mark 7:1–23 gives a particular controversy: some disciples eat with hands described as defiled, that is, unwashed, and Pharisees and scribes ask why they do not follow the elders' tradition. The washing concerns ritual purity; it is not a lesson about modern germ theory. Mark's explanatory generalization about Jewish practice should also be read as part of his account, rather than treated as a statistical survey of every Jewish household.

Jesus answers by contrasting God's command to honor parents with a use of Corban, which Mark explains as a gift dedicated to God. A person could invoke that dedication so that resources would not be available for a parent's support. The criticism targets a practice that allowed an obligation to parents to be set aside; it does not require assuming that the money had already been paid into the temple treasury. The USCCB notes on Mark 7:3, 5 and 11 explain the purity custom, inherited tradition and dedication vow.

What Were the Disputes About?

Read the issue and Jesus' response together
Encounter Passages What the exchange emphasizes
Eating with tax collectors and sinners Matthew 9:9–13; Mark 2:13–17; Luke 5:27–32. Jesus explains his mission through the physician image and, in Matthew, the priority of mercy.
Fasting Matthew 9:14–17; Mark 2:18–22; Luke 5:33–39. The presence of the bridegroom and the images of cloth and wineskins frame the question of appropriate practice.
Plucking grain on the Sabbath Matthew 12:1–8; Mark 2:23–28. Hunger, David, the priests in Matthew, mercy and the Son of man's authority belong to the argument. The dispute cannot be reduced to an amusing rule about one grain.
Healing on the Sabbath Matthew 12:9–14; Mark 3:1–6; Luke 14:1–6. Jesus asks about doing good and saving life. Mark also records the ensuing plot with the Herodians.
Washing and Corban Matthew 15:1–20; Mark 7:1–23. Jesus challenges a tradition that defeats a commandment and directs attention to the evil that comes from within a person.

The Pharisee in Luke 18:9–14 says that he fasts twice a week and gives tithes. Jesus directs the parable toward people who trust in their own righteousness and despise others. One character's speech is not a membership survey proving that every Pharisee followed precisely that weekly routine.

Why Did Jesus Criticize Them?

Matthew 23 describes burdens placed on others, conspicuous religious display, pursuit of honor, hypocrisy and neglect of weightier matters. In verse 23, Jesus names judgment, mercy and faith alongside the tithing of herbs, and says the former should be done without leaving the latter undone. The point is distorted if it becomes either a rejection of every outward practice or approval of meticulous observance without justice.

Luke 11:37–54 also joins outward cleansing with inward greed and injustice. These criticisms ask whether conduct matches professed devotion. They do not establish that every member had the same motives, and they offer no basis for claiming Jesus criticized the group simply because it was popular.

The USCCB introduction to the notes on Matthew 23 distinguishes the conflict involving Jesus from the Gospel's later community setting and its warning to Christian readers. Readers should attend to the force of the criticism without turning it into hostility toward Jewish people or using it only to accuse another community.

Different People and Responses

Party identity does not predict every action
Person or scene Evidence What can be concluded
Nicodemus John 3:1–21; 7:45–52; 19:38–42. He questions Jesus, challenges judgment without a hearing and later brings burial spices. Read the development across the three scenes.
A Pharisee's meal Luke 7:36–50. Simon hosts Jesus but misunderstands the woman and the meaning of forgiveness. Hosting and disagreement occur in the same encounter.
Warning about Herod Luke 13:31–35. Some Pharisees tell Jesus that Herod wants to kill him. The warning is recorded without a complete account of their motives.
Gamaliel Acts 5:34–40. A Pharisee urges the council to leave the apostles alone. This intervention is not a statement that he has accepted all their teaching.
Believers from the party Acts 15:1–11. Some believers who belonged to the Pharisees argue for circumcision and keeping Moses' law. Their presence and the resulting disagreement are explicit; the text gives no percentage of the church.

Resurrection and Paul's Background

Acts 23:6–9 contrasts the parties over resurrection, angels and spirit. Paul appeals to the hope and resurrection of the dead, and some Pharisaic scribes speak in his favor. Their response in this hearing does not mean they endorse his entire message about Jesus.

Josephus also contrasts the parties concerning human choice, fate and life after death (Antiquities 18.1.3–4). His categories and wording should not be assumed identical to Paul's explanation of resurrection. Paul's own recollection of being a Pharisee belongs beside his reassessment of his former advantages in light of Christ (Philippians 3:5–11). See Paul's Pharisaic background for that distinction.

Sources and Further Reading

  1. Biblical reading: the Gospel passages and Acts scenes cited in each section; also Matthew 3:1–12; 16:1–12; 22:15–46; Philippians 3:1–11. Short quotations use the KJV. The comparisons and explanations are independently written.
  2. Josephus: the linked selections of Antiquities 13.10.5–6 and 18.1.2–4, in William Whiston's translation at Project Gutenberg. These are historical witnesses with a perspective, not neutral descriptions of every individual.
  3. Lexical and interpretive help: the linked G5330 entry is used for the name, not a proven founding date. The linked USCCB NABRE notes on Mark 7 and Matthew 23 are used for the specific interpretive questions identified above, with explanation in our own words.

Compare the Sadducees and the Sanhedrin. Our editorial policy explains how we distinguish scripture, historical evidence and interpretation.