High Priest and Priests in the New Testament: Roles and People
The New Testament distinguishes the serving high priest from the chief-priestly leadership and the wider body of priests. Zechariah's incense service, Caiaphas's role in a council and the priests who join the Christian movement describe different people and situations. Reading the terms in context prevents a picture in which every priest has the same authority or takes part in every action.
Four Related Terms
| Term | Role or usage | Example and boundary |
|---|---|---|
| High priest | The leading priestly office; a former holder may also retain the title in a narrative. | John 18:13 names Caiaphas as the serving high priest; Acts 4:6 also calls Annas high priest. |
| Chief priests | The plural identifies a wider priestly leadership rather than every ordinary priest. | Matthew 26:3 groups chief priests with elders at Caiaphas's palace. The verse does not list all members of the leadership. |
| Priests | Members of the priestly body carrying out sanctuary service; individual priests can appear apart from the governing leadership. | Luke 1:5–23 identifies Zechariah and his division. Acts 6:7 reports many priests accepting the faith. |
| Levites | A related group with supporting sanctuary responsibilities, distinguished from Aaron's priestly household in the Torah. | Numbers 3:5–10; 18:1–7. Levitical ancestry does not give every person the same altar duties. |
These are not four interchangeable names for one political party. Nor does the plural “chief priests” require several people to hold the sole current high-priestly office at the same time. The narrative may be speaking about a wider circle of priestly authority, including the high-priestly household, as Acts 4:5–6 explicitly illustrates.
Priestly Divisions and Zechariah
First Chronicles 24:1–19 presents the division of Aaron's descendants into twenty-four groups, with sixteen from Eleazar's line and eight from Ithamar's. The account associates their organization with David, Zadok and Ahimelech and describes allocation by lot. Abijah receives the eighth lot (24:10).
Luke 1:5 identifies Zechariah—Zacharias in the KJV—as belonging to the division of Abijah, spelled Abia there. While his division is serving, the lot falls to him to offer incense, and the people pray outside. The narrative ends this episode with his return home when his period of service is completed (1:8–23). That is a concrete example of a priest serving with his division, not evidence that Zechariah is the high priest or that he enters the innermost sanctuary on the Day of Atonement.
The same passage describes Elizabeth as descended from Aaron and calls the couple righteous before God. It gives a household beyond the elite council scenes. His return home also cautions against assuming that every priest must reside permanently beside the temple. A precise reconstruction of residential arrangements for all divisions would require further historical evidence.
Inheritance and Political Appointment
The priesthood's hereditary framework comes from Exodus 28:1 and the rules for Aaron's descendants. Later appointment to the leading office also involved political power. Josephus, writing after the events, describes the Roman administrator Valerius Gratus removing Ananus, appointing several successors and eventually appointing Joseph Caiaphas (Antiquities 18.2.2, Whiston translation).
This is specific historical testimony about Roman administration, not an appointment procedure stated in the Gospels. It supports distinguishing priestly descent from uninterrupted tenure. A blanket statement that only the Great Sanhedrin could appoint every high priest, in every period, does not describe the appointments Josephus records.
The NABRE note on Luke 3:2 dates Annas's tenure to AD 6–15 and Caiaphas's to AD 18–36. These are historical dates supplied by the commentary, not dates printed in Luke's verse. John 11:49, 51 calls Caiaphas high priest “that year”; the expression identifies the significant year of the narrative and should not be expanded into a rule that the office rotated annually.
Regulations and Qualifications
Leviticus 21:10–15 sets out the high priest's special restrictions concerning mourning, contact with the dead and marriage. The marriage described is to a virgin of his own people. The following regulations restrict certain priests' approach to the altar because of bodily conditions but preserve their access to sacred food (21:16–23). These texts describe ritual eligibility, not a hierarchy of human worth.
The often-cited age of twenty needs a different explanation. Second Chronicles 31:15–19 concerns registration and distribution of portions among priestly and Levitical households; verse 17 specifically mentions Levites aged twenty and above. It is not a law fixing the minimum age for appointment as high priest. Claims about an obligatory level of wealth, exceptional physical superiority or a requirement to enrich a poor appointee belong to particular later traditions and need to be cited as such. They cannot be inferred from this verse.
The high priest's annual sanctuary responsibilities are explained in the guide to the office and the Day of Atonement. Luke's account of an ordinary priest offering incense should be kept distinct from those rites.
Why Do Annas and Caiaphas Both Appear?
Luke 3:2 associates both names with the high priesthood, and Acts 4:6 calls Annas high priest while also naming Caiaphas and members of the high-priestly family. John supplies an important relationship: Annas is Caiaphas's father-in-law, and Caiaphas is high priest that year (18:13).
The NABRE explanation of Luke 3:2 connects Annas's continuing prominence with his influence or continued use of the title after removal. It does not require us to invent two equal simultaneous tenures. Historical tenure and a narrative's way of referring to an influential former officeholder are different kinds of information.
John says Jesus is brought to Annas first, then describes questioning about his disciples and teaching, and in 18:24 records Annas sending him bound to Caiaphas. The NABRE notes on John 18:13, 24 distinguish this inquiry from the scene before Caiaphas in Matthew and Mark. A comparison should retain what each Gospel actually narrates instead of treating the two names as interchangeable or silently combining all dialogue into one hearing.
Leaders in the Arrest and Trial Accounts
Matthew 26:3–5 places a gathering of chief priests and elders at Caiaphas's palace to plan Jesus' arrest and death. When Judas approaches, Matthew specifically names the chief priests as those who agree to pay thirty pieces of silver (26:14–16). Describing the transaction merely as something “the elders” do loses the text's identification of the participants.
Matthew 26:57–68 and Mark 14:53–65 describe testimony, questioning by the high priest, the charge of blasphemy and a judgment that Jesus deserves death. Their accounts condemn false testimony and mistreatment. They provide evidence about the leaders in those scenes; they do not establish how every ordinary priest in Judea thought or acted.
John 18:28–40 then moves from Caiaphas to Pilate. John 19:1–16 includes Roman scourging and soldiers, demands for crucifixion, Pilate's questioning and his handing Jesus over for crucifixion. The involvement of particular chief priests should be described alongside the Roman governor's authority and action, rather than assigning the entire process to an undifferentiated religious group.
John 18:31 reports the speakers telling Pilate that they lack the right to execute anyone. The NABRE note on that verse cautions that the historical scope of the council's capital jurisdiction is not clear. The verse is evidence for the claim in this narrative; a complete legal history requires more than quoting it as a timeless rule.
Priests Did Not All Respond Alike
Acts 4:1–7 describes opposition to Peter and John by priests, the temple captain and Sadducees, followed by a gathering of rulers, elders, scribes and the high-priestly family. Acts 6:7, however, says that a large company of priests becomes obedient to the faith. Luke 1 has already portrayed Zechariah and Elizabeth positively. The sources present differing responses; they supply no percentage establishing that “most priests” opposed Jesus.
Likewise, Luke 2:22–38 describes Simeon as a righteous, devout man and Anna as a prophetess. Although the scene occurs in the temple, the passage does not call Simeon a priest or high priest. A later painting of the presentation is not evidence for assigning him that office.
Hebrews' description of Jesus as high priest is a further, theological use of the title. For how it connects his ministry with God's oath and an enduring life, see The Order of Melchizedek. That argument should be distinguished from a historical list of people administering Jerusalem's temple.
Sources and Reading Notes
This independently written guide checks 1 Chronicles 24:1–19; 2 Chronicles 31:15–19; Luke 1:5–23; 2:22–38; 3:1–3; John 11:45–53; 18:12–40; 19:1–16; Matthew 26:1–5, 14–16, 57–68; Mark 14:53–65; and Acts 4:1–7; 6:1–7 against the priestly regulations in Exodus 28 and Leviticus 16, 21. Short quotations use the King James Version. Abia/Abijah and Zacharias/Zechariah are spelling forms in the cited translations.
Historical and interpretive material is attributed to USCCB/NABRE Luke 3, John 18 and Josephus, Antiquities 18.2.2, read in the Whiston translation hosted by Project Gutenberg. The Josephus consultation covers that specific paragraph, not an exhaustive review of his works. For the earlier office, read Who Was the High Priest?; our editorial and source policy explains the treatment of evidence and uncertainty.