What Are the Gospels? Four Books, Shared Stories and Their Origins
The four Gospel books of the New Testament are Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. They tell about Jesus through accounts of his words, deeds, death and resurrection. Their names, shared material and different presentations raise related questions: how should they be read together, and what can be said about their authors and dates?
How Does Each Book Begin?
The openings immediately offer different ways into the accounts. Matthew 1:1 begins with Jesus Christ as son of David and son of Abraham, followed by a genealogy. Mark 1:1–15 introduces the gospel of Jesus Christ, John the Baptist and the beginning of Jesus' proclamation in Galilee.
Luke 1:1–4 addresses Theophilus, refers to earlier accounts and traditions handed down by eyewitnesses, and explains the purpose of an orderly account: assurance about what the reader has been taught. John 1:1–18 begins with the Word, creation, life and light, before speaking of the Word becoming flesh. John 20:30–31 later explicitly connects the book's selected signs with belief in Jesus as the Christ, the Son of God, and life in his name.
These observations come from the passages. They provide a starting point for reading without requiring speculative biographies or treating one opening as the only correct approach to Jesus.
What Does the Synoptic Grouping Describe?
Matthew, Mark and Luke are commonly grouped as the Synoptic Gospels because much of their narrative material can be studied alongside one another. John has a substantially different arrangement and extensive material of its own. The grouping concerns literary relationships, not a judgment that John has no connection with the others.
The USCCB Matthew introduction discusses shared material and the theory that Matthew and Luke used Mark alongside other sources. Its account includes a proposed sayings source conventionally called Q. That is a scholarly explanation of relationships among the texts, rather than a separately available Gospel book identified in these opening verses. The John introduction discusses John's different order, stories and theological presentation.
How Can a Shared Story Be Compared?
The feeding of the five thousand supplies a useful example in all four books: Matthew 14:13–21; Mark 6:30–44; Luke 9:10–17; John 6:1–15. Each account describes five loaves, two fish, a large crowd being fed and twelve baskets remaining.
The accounts also include details that guide attention differently. Matthew describes compassion and healing. Mark places the apostles' return and an invitation to rest before the gathering, then describes compassion and teaching. Luke names Bethsaida and speaks of the kingdom and healing. John names Philip and Andrew, identifies a boy with barley loaves, and ends with the crowd's attempt to make Jesus king and his withdrawal.
First read each account through, then record what each states. Avoid supplying one book's detail as though all four expressly stated it. The shared event allows comparison; it does not mean that every difference has been explained merely by comparing the books to cameras at different angles.
Who Wrote the Books, and When?
The traditional titles name Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. Historical questions about those attributions require more than assuming that a title or narrative voice settles the composition of the complete book. The consulted USCCB introductions distinguish traditions about authors from modern assessments of sources and editing.
For example, the Mark introduction describes the book as anonymous apart from its ancient heading and recounts its traditional association with John Mark and Peter. The Luke introduction identifies the later tradition associating Luke and Acts with Luke, while noting the author's reliance on eyewitness traditions. The John introduction distinguishes the tradition of eyewitness testimony from questions about the editing of the present text. Its traditional identification with John son of Zebedee is not treated there as a settled modern conclusion.
| Book | Estimate in that introduction | What kind of claim it is |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew | After AD 70, probably at least a decade later. | An assessment based in part on its proposed use of Mark and interpretation of references to Jerusalem. |
| Mark | Traditionally shortly before AD 70; modern proposals also include shortly after 70. | Alternative historical reconstructions, rather than a date supplied by the book. |
| Luke | After AD 70, with AD 80–90 proposed by many scholars. | An estimate involving sources and the interpretation of passages about Jerusalem. |
| John | Final editing and present arrangement probably AD 90–100. | A proposal about the present form, allowing a history of composition and editing. |
These are the assessments of the named introductions, not exact dates universally agreed upon or dates stated in the Gospel openings. The Matthew introduction itself cautions that answers about authorship, sources and composition carry degrees of probability. Reading a book's opening or ending cannot establish a precise year such as AD 35 or AD 42 on its own.
How Can I Begin Reading?
Choose an account and read connected sections before making a composite timeline. Mark 1 offers an entry through the beginning of public proclamation; Luke 1:1–4 explains the narrator's purpose; John 1 and 20:24–31 frame the relation of the Word, signs and belief; Matthew 1 opens through genealogy and Israel's named ancestors. Then try the feeding comparison above, keeping each account's sequence visible.
For the different question of “gospel” as the message proclaimed, see What Is the Gospel? A written account and the proclamation it presents are related, but they are not interchangeable terms.
Sources and the Limits of This Guide
Primary reading: Matthew 1:1–6 and 14:13–21; Mark 1:1–15 and 6:30–44; Luke 1:1–4 and 9:10–17; John 1:1–18, 6:1–15 and 20:24–31, checked against the King James Version text.
The USCCB introductions to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John were consulted for literary relationships, traditional attributions and their historical estimates. Their wider theological interpretations are not all being adopted here. This introductory comparison does not establish the history of the four-book canon or settle every problem of harmonization.