What Are Exegesis and Eisegesis? A Worked Reading Example

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

Exegesis is the critical explanation of a text; eisegesis is interpretation that imposes the reader's own ideas on it. The distinction concerns how an interpretation is supported. A strong reading explains why its conclusion fits the words and context, and remains open to correction when the passage supplies contrary evidence.

What the Terms Mean

The American Heritage Dictionary defines exegesis as critical explanation or analysis, especially of a text. Dictionary.com's entry for eisegesis describes interpretation that expresses the interpreter's own ideas or biases rather than the text's meaning. Both terms can be used in discussions beyond the Bible.

The contrast is not between having no assumptions and having assumptions. Readers bring questions, beliefs and experiences to a passage. The practical issue is whether they make the text answer a question it does not address, disregard inconvenient details or present their own added idea as though it were the writer's statement.

“I Can Do All Things” in Context

Philippians 4:13 says, “I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me” in the KJV. On its own, the sentence might be used to promise success at any ambition. Read verses 10–20 before deciding what “all things” includes here.

Paul thanks the Philippians for renewed care. He says he has learned contentment in different circumstances, including hunger and plenty, abundance and need (verses 11–12). The sentence about strength follows those contrasts. He then commends their sharing in his affliction and describes the gifts they sent (verses 14–18).

A reading supported by that paragraph concerns Christ's strengthening Paul through changing circumstances, including deprivation. It does not make receiving help unnecessary: Paul explicitly appreciates the gift. A guarantee that every desired achievement will succeed adds something the paragraph does not promise, especially when hunger and need are among its stated circumstances.

Testing an Interpretation

Write down the proposed meaning and the details supporting it. In this example, record the contrasts in verse 12, the connection to verse 13 and the thanksgiving that follows. Then identify a detail that would challenge your explanation. If the reading requires Paul never to experience need, verse 12 is an immediate problem.

A dictionary or commentary can help investigate a question, but citing one is not a replacement for explaining the passage. Equally, disagreeing with a commentator is not by itself evidence of eisegesis. The relevant question is how each reading accounts for the text.

Interpretation and Application

A Christian reader may find encouragement to face a difficult situation in this paragraph. That application should remain connected to its subject: contentment, dependence on Christ and meaningful help from others. Turning it into a guarantee of a particular outcome changes the claim.

These terms do not require a two-part classification in which every interpretation is either “rational” and unbelieving or “revealed” and correct. A declaration of faith does not remove the need to explain the passage, and the label eisegesis should not serve as a substitute for identifying what a rival interpretation adds or overlooks.

Sources and Further Study

Definitions: American Heritage, “exegesis”; Dictionary.com, “eisegesis”. Primary example: Philippians 4:4–20, read in the King James Version. The explanation focuses on the paragraph's expressed contrasts and thanksgiving; it is not an exhaustive word study of every occurrence of “all.”

For the wider question of interpretive methods, read hermeneutics. For a guided first attempt, use the passage exercise in the beginner's study workflow.