What Does Agnostic Mean?

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

An agnostic, in a common religious use, suspends judgment about whether God exists. The word can also describe a position about the limits of knowledge: God’s existence or nonexistence is not known, or cannot be known. Those meanings are related, but they make different claims.

To understand someone’s use of the label, ask what the person believes and what the person claims to know. A definition can clarify those questions without settling whether God exists. It also cannot reveal a person’s motives, scientific education or moral character.

What Kind of Uncertainty?

“I do not know” reports a limit in the speaker’s knowledge. “Nobody currently knows” extends that judgment to other people. “Nobody could ever know” is a stronger claim about what is possible. Calling all three statements agnostic does not make them interchangeable.

Here are examples of statements a reader might encounter. They are illustrations of the distinctions, rather than quotations from a survey or a classification imposed on every person.

Ask which claim is actually being made
Illustrative statement What it addresses What remains to ask
I have not decided whether God exists. Suspension of judgment. What question or evidence would help the person decide?
I believe God exists, but I do not claim to know. Belief accompanied by a limit on knowledge. What distinction is the speaker making between belief and knowledge?
I do not believe in God, but I cannot prove that no god exists. Lack of belief accompanied by a limit on proof. Does the speaker also affirm that no god exists?
Human beings cannot know whether God exists. A general claim about the possibility of knowledge. What argument supports that limit?

The last statement needs more support than the first. Someone’s present uncertainty does not by itself establish a permanent boundary for all human knowledge. Conversely, believing a proposition does not automatically mean claiming certainty about it.

Is an Agnostic an Atheist?

It depends on the definitions in use. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy distinguishes atheism as the claim that God does not exist from the broader use meaning an absence of belief in God. It likewise distinguishes agnosticism as suspension of judgment from agnosticism as a position about knowledge.

Under the first comparison, theist, atheist and agnostic describe belief, denial and suspended judgment. Under the broader use of atheist, someone who suspends judgment can lack belief in God and therefore fall within that category. Labels such as “agnostic atheist” use the knowledge and belief questions together. They need not mean that the speaker both affirms and denies the same proposition.

These are differences in terminology worth clarifying before debating a claim. A person can explain their position in a full sentence more precisely than a single label permits. The label alone also does not tell us whether someone belongs to a religious organization or takes part in worship.

What Did Huxley Mean?

The modern term is associated with the nineteenth-century English biologist Thomas Henry Huxley. His essay Agnosticism (1889), reprinted in Collected Essays, volume V, supplies his own retrospective account. On printed pages 238–240 he describes feeling out of place among the confidently labeled members of the Metaphysical Society and devising “agnostic” as a contrasting label to the Gnostics of church history, who professed knowledge he did not possess.

On pages 245–247, Huxley describes agnosticism as “not a creed, but a method.” He urges following reason and avoiding assertions of certainty beyond what can be demonstrated. He also allows that later discoveries can change what is established. This is more informative than treating his term simply as another name for indifference to religion.

Huxley explicitly speaks for himself. His essay is evidence for his explanation and argument, rather than a creed binding everyone who now uses the word. A modern reader may adopt the label while disagreeing with aspects of his wider religious criticism.

Did Acts Already Use the Modern Word?

Acts 17:23 records Paul referring to an altar inscription rendered in the KJV as “TO THE UNKNOWN GOD.” The Greek adjective indexed by Blue Letter Bible as G57 is ἄγνωστος, transliterated agnōstos, meaning unknown. The lexicon identifies an adjective describing the god in the inscription. It does not identify the worshipers as members of a modern philosophical movement.

This ancient vocabulary helps explain the word family behind the English term. It does not displace Huxley’s account of devising the modern label. An older Greek adjective and a later English name for a position can share linguistic roots while having different histories and uses.

Read the inscription in the whole speech. Paul moves from what the Athenians worship without knowing to his proclamation of the Creator, then to repentance, judgment and resurrection (Acts 17:24–31). Verses 32–34 report different responses. The account describes worship and proclamation; it does not supply a census of agnostics or a psychological account of why modern people doubt.

For the setting and the meaning of Areopagus, see Mars Hill and the Areopagus. For the argument of the address, follow Paul’s preaching in Athens.

How to Use the Term in a Conversation

Start with the specific proposition under discussion. Uncertainty about the existence of any deity is a different question from uncertainty about a particular account of God, a miracle or a doctrine. A person may regard one claim as unsupported while accepting another.

Then establish whether the speaker is describing present belief, personal knowledge or what anyone could know. Finally, examine the reasons offered for that particular claim. The term agnostic helps locate the discussion; the evidence and argument still have to do the work.

Sources and Further Reading

  • Paul Draper, “Atheism and Agnosticism,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, sections 1–2, for differing current philosophical and broader uses. This entry identifies contested definitions rather than prescribing everyone’s self-description.
  • T. H. Huxley, “Agnosticism” (1889), Collected Essays V, especially printed pages 238–240 and 245–247. Consulted transcription of Huxley’s essay.
  • Blue Letter Bible, G57, for the adjective, transliteration and Acts 17:23 reference. The altar’s legendary history is not used as evidence here.
  • Primary biblical account: Acts 17:16–34, checked in the KJV. No ancient inscription or modern demographic survey was independently examined for this entry.

Continue to the dictionary of biblical terms or the guide to using Greek and Hebrew language tools.