History of the Early Church: From Jewish Beginnings to Constantine

Question?  -   Contact  -   Revised

The early Christian church began among Jewish followers of Jesus and expanded to include Gentiles. Acts records that expansion alongside continuing Jewish worship practices, disagreements and shared decisions. Later sources show communities developing different forms of leadership and observance. The history therefore needs dates, places and identifiable witnesses: a change in Jerusalem does not automatically describe every church.

This guide follows selected developments from Acts into the early fourth century. For the biblical narrative itself, use the Acts reading guide and chapter-by-chapter Acts timeline.

What Were the Church's Jewish Roots?

Acts 2 places the gift of the Spirit at Pentecost in Jerusalem. Its listeners include Jews and proselytes associated with many lands. Peter explains Jesus' resurrection through Israel's Scriptures and calls his hearers to repentance and baptism. Believers continue in the apostles' teaching, fellowship, meals and prayers, gathering in the temple and in homes (2:1–47).

Those details matter. The narrative does not begin with a Gentile institution replacing everything Jewish. Much later in Acts, Paul defends his worship of the God of his ancestors and his belief in the law and prophets (24:14–15). The accusation that he leads the sect of the Nazarenes belongs to his accuser's speech in 24:5; readers should distinguish that accusation from Paul's own explanation.

The first community also experienced opposition and internal problems. The separate guide to Jerusalem's life in Acts 2–6 examines its sharing, threats and care for widows. An account of universally peaceful Christians lasting until the second century would already conflict with the disputes in Acts 15.

What Changed When Gentiles Joined?

At Cornelius's house, Peter's Gentile hearers receive the Spirit and are baptized (Acts 10). In Acts 15, some teachers demand circumcision as necessary for salvation. The Jerusalem gathering hears Peter's testimony, Barnabas and Paul's report, and James's appeal to the prophets. Its letter rejects the unauthorized demand and gives instructions concerning idolatry, sexual conduct, blood and strangled animals (15:1–29).

Gentile inclusion and the abandonment of Jewish identity are different propositions. Acts 21:17–26 still describes many Jewish believers as zealous for the law, while distinguishing the instructions already sent to Gentiles. These scenes show people negotiating shared community across inherited boundaries. They do not establish a single date on which all Christians ceased every Jewish practice.

What Happened to Jerusalem?

Jerusalem's destruction and the later revolt under Hadrian are important turning points, but our sources require care. Eusebius, writing in the fourth century, reports an earlier Christian departure to Pella before the war in which Jerusalem was destroyed. His account is a later report, not an eyewitness description of a postwar Christian rebuilding project (Church History III.5).

In IV.5, Eusebius lists fifteen Jerusalem leaders whom he describes as of Hebrew descent before the revolt under Hadrian. He also explicitly says he lacked a written chronology for their tenures. In IV.6, he reports the exclusion of Jews from the Jerusalem area after the revolt and identifies Marcus as the first Gentile leader of the resulting Gentile church. The following table keeps his local account separate from developments elsewhere.

Different places, different evidence
Period and place Evidence What it establishes
First-century Jerusalem and Gentile mission Acts 2; 10; 15; 21 Jewish beginnings and Gentile inclusion, with distinct questions about inherited practice.
Jerusalem before the war ending in AD 70 Eusebius III.5 A later report of departure to Pella; it does not document Christians rebuilding the city.
Jerusalem after the revolt ending in AD 135 Eusebius IV.5–6 A reported local change from Hebrew to Gentile leadership under Roman restrictions.
Second-century communities addressed by Ignatius and Justin Smyrnaeans 8; First Apology 67 Evidence for episcopal leadership and Sunday assembly in those writers' accounts.
Late second-century Asia Minor and Rome Eusebius V.23–24 Disagreement over the annual paschal observance, including resistance to Rome's Victor.
Early fourth-century empire Eusebius X.5 Imperial protection, property restoration and intervention in church disputes.

Eusebius interprets the Jewish wars in strongly polemical theological language. Reporting his information about leaders or migration does not require adopting his condemnation of Jewish people. Nor does his Jerusalem succession list demonstrate that the loss of Jewish leadership caused every later doctrinal change across the empire.

How Did Leadership and Worship Develop?

Ignatius's letter to the Smyrnaeans, chapter 8, urges obedience to a bishop alongside presbyters and deacons, and connects authorized communal worship with the bishop. It is evidence for the leadership he advocated in that setting. It cannot, by itself, date an identical organizational transition in every city.

Justin's First Apology 67 describes Sunday gatherings with readings, instruction, prayers, bread and wine, and contributions for people in need. He connects the day with creation and Jesus' resurrection. Thus Sunday assembly appears in this second-century testimony before Constantine. A Roman name for the weekday alone cannot establish that the worship described was directed toward the sun.

Uniformity was also contested. Eusebius preserves accounts of churches in Asia observing the paschal date on the fourteenth day of the lunar month, while others followed a Sunday observance. When Victor of Rome sought to exclude the Asian churches, other bishops objected. Irenaeus favored Sunday observance yet urged peace (V.23–24). Annual paschal dating and the weekly assembly are related historical subjects, but they are not the same dispute.

What Changed Under Constantine?

Eusebius X.5 reproduces imperial documents associated with Constantine and Licinius, including the religious-liberty settlement of AD 313. They provide for Christian worship and the return of confiscated property. The chapter also preserves Constantine's letters arranging hearings and assemblies over disputes involving African churches.

These documents show a changed relationship between rulers and churches: protection and assistance were accompanied by imperial involvement in church affairs. They do not describe Christianity being invented in 313, nor do they make every later institution or disputed practice the product of one decision. The same chapter records divisions that imperial support had not simply erased.

How Can We Assess Doctrinal Changes?

Begin with a specific teaching or practice. Identify its biblical basis, its earliest relevant witnesses and the places where those witnesses apply. Distinguish a writer's description from his instruction, and both from a later historian's interpretation. To assess a writer such as Tertullian or Origen, examine a particular work and argument rather than treating the author's name as proof of either universal agreement or universal decline.

A useful reading exercise is to compare Acts 15 with the paschal controversy preserved in Eusebius V.23–24. Ask who speaks, what evidence is offered, how dissent is handled and whether the account describes one congregation or several regions. This approach leaves room for a reasoned theological judgment while making the historical steps open to examination.

Sources and Further Reading